ResLife: Designing for Disagreements

Every residence life staffer I have ever met has received some variation of this text from a student staff member:

“Hey, it got a little tense in the lounge tonight… I don’t know what to do…”

It’s the text that signals conflict that isn’t about sleeping schedules or the visitation policy. It’s something deeper and more meaningful, something college-age students have not yet learned to navigate. To be fair to our students, and to what we know about student development theory, that is right on track. Working through divisive conflict is hard, and perhaps harder now, in a climate that does not seem to value community care. Our collective commitment to teaching students to navigate difference has never been more important.

Disagreement in community isn’t a crisis to manage. It’s a skill students can learn, and residence halls are where they first practice it. College is supposed to be the place where we engage in big debates and learn to have constructive conflict that leads to intellectual growth and curiosity. In fact, learning requires some cognitive conflict: the friction that occurs when new information clashes with your existing beliefs. In practice, that friction shows up in the residence halls before it shows up anywhere else.

We already anticipate some types of conflict. We treat roommate conflict as a foregone conclusion and as a vital learning opportunity. If we are not explicitly teaching staff at all levels that complicated social conflict is also a) inevitable and b) a learning opportunity, we are missing the mark. The models and curricula we design should anticipate it, and our staff should be prepared to respond at the most appropriate level. Our role is to model and teach how to stay in community, not what our students or staff should believe.

That means building the structure so it doesn’t rely on a heroic RA being asked to facilitate beyond their capacity on topics they are uncomfortable with. It is tempting to be only reactive, to throw a program or a hastily written email at the problem. But doing our best thinking in our worst moments rarely leads to good outcomes. Some alternatives to consider:

  • Scaffold these opportunities over the year. Start small and early. Roommate agreements and community agreements are students’ first practice in naming what they need, hearing what someone else needs, and finding something workable in between. Later in the year, the stakes can rise: floor decisions about shared space, structured conversations, and reflection on how residents handled disagreement. By the time something truly divisive happens, students have already practiced the basic steps.
  • Map predictable high-tension moments onto our frameworks, and plan for them the same way we plan for midterms and move-out. We can’t predict every incident, but we can predict a lot: elections, major news events, anniversaries, and the moments our own campuses tend to feel strain. Put them on the curricular calendar. Decide ahead of time what staff will do, what supervisors will check in about, and what support residents can expect, so no one is designing a response at 11 p.m.
  • Equip staff ahead of time. That includes conversation guides, social norming campaigns, clear referral pathways, and practicing level-appropriate facilitation. Every role doesn’t need to do everything. An RA might name the tension, set a norm, and know who to call. A hall director might facilitate a floor conversation. Central staff might coordinate a larger response. When each level knows its part, and has practiced it, the RA texting at night isn’t carrying the whole community alone.

Belonging and safety still come first. Teaching students to disagree well does not mean asking them to tolerate harassment, threats, or bias for the sake of dialogue. Some disagreements cross into harm, and those follow your existing response and reporting processes, not a facilitation guide. Staff need to know where that line is and feel confident moving from “let’s talk about this” to “this needs a different response.” Being clear about that boundary is what makes it safe for everyone else to stay in the conversation.

So, where in your model do your students practice disagreeing well? Look at your learning goals, your calendar, and your staff training, and find the places where this skill is being taught on purpose rather than left to chance. If you can find them, then when that text comes in, you can reply, “Ok, deep breath. We practiced for this.”

Erin Simpson

Dr. Erin Simpson (she/her/hers) serves the Division of Student Affairs at the University of Oklahoma as an Assistant Vice President and Assistant Dean of Students. She has the good fortune to work with a wide array of departments that serve students through advocacy and education, community connections and student engagement, and orientation programs. Erin also supervises the Student Affairs curriculum and assessment of divisional efforts. She frequently consults with institutions across the country to bring scalable, equity minded practices to divisions of Student Affairs. Her work is dedicated to creating spaces for all students to feel welcomed and affirmed.

Comments are closed.

Up ↑